AeroLeads people directory · profile

Stephen Lothrop Email & Phone Number

Arbitration Specialist at Hagerty
Location: Columbus, Ohio, United States 10 work roles 1 school
1 work email found @hagerty.com 5 phones found area 614, 352, and 850 LinkedIn matched
✓ Verified Jul 2026 4 data sources Profile completeness 100%

Contact Signals · 1 work email · 5 phones

Work email s****@hagerty.com
Direct phone (614) ***-****
LinkedIn Profile matched
3 free lookups remaining · No credit card
Current company
Role
Arbitration Specialist
Location
Columbus, Ohio, United States
Company size

Who is Stephen Lothrop? Overview

A concise factual answer block for searchers comparing this professional profile.

Quick answer

Stephen Lothrop is listed as Arbitration Specialist at Hagerty, a with 11 employees, based in Columbus, Ohio, United States. AeroLeads shows a work email signal at hagerty.com, phone signal with area code 614, 352, 850, and a matched LinkedIn profile for Stephen Lothrop.

Stephen Lothrop previously worked as Managed Repair Representative at Progressive Insurance and Automobile Subrogation Specialist at Nationwide. Stephen Lothrop holds Bachelor Of Arts (B.A.), Philosophy from University Of Florida.

Company email context

Email format at Hagerty

This section adds company-level context without repeating Stephen Lothrop's masked contact details.

{first_initial}{last}@hagerty.com
86% confidence

AeroLeads found 1 current-domain work email signal for Stephen Lothrop. Compare company email patterns before reaching out.

Profile bio

About Stephen Lothrop

Top Ranked Senior Arbitration Professional with 15+ years’ experience. Demonstrated success in negotiatingand securing a high volume of recoveries. Results-oriented leader, who has the vision, communication skills,and interpersonal savvy to effectively enable, educate and motivate associates to exceed team goals. ClaimSpecialist proficient in the interpretation of state law, policy language, and settlement practices across multiple insurance product lines and coverage contracts.

Listed skills include Food, Craft Beer, and Beer.

Current workplace

Stephen Lothrop's current company

Company context helps verify the profile and gives searchers a useful next step.

Hagerty
Hagerty
Arbitration Specialist
Columbus, OH, US
Employees
11
AeroLeads page
10 roles · 25 years

Stephen Lothrop work experience

A career timeline built from the work history available for this profile.

Arbitration Specialist

Columbus, Oh, Us

Arbitration Specialist

Traverse City, Michigan, United States

Mentor claims department staff while distinguishing myself as the Subject Matter Expert on liability theory, arbitration potential, and evidence utilization.Calibrate processes to ensure team members are using accurate and effective policies and procedures in multiple jurisdictions for property and casualty losses.Review claim files to assess the cause of action, evaluate recovery potential, plan recovery strategy, document action, and follow up to achieve a fair and equitable… Show more Mentor claims department staff while distinguishing myself as the Subject Matter Expert on liability theory, arbitration potential, and evidence utilization.Calibrate processes to ensure team members are using accurate and effective policies and procedures in multiple jurisdictions for property and casualty losses.Review claim files to assess the cause of action, evaluate recovery potential, plan recovery strategy, document action, and follow up to achieve a fair and equitable disposition.Collaborate with legal counsel on suit filings, cause and origin reporting, and the implementation of forensic engineering experts all while keeping a keen eye on the projected litigation expense budget to ensure a worthwhile return on investment.Streamline problematic procedures; for example, maximized recoveries on duplicate payment of funds, reworded multiple customer/b2b communications to clarify ambiguous language, and enabled safeguards to preserve statute of limitation for 'at-risk' files.Identify areas of growth in talent for the team; proposed an entry level role on the team to field the more data entry driven aspects of the job allowing the experienced and proven negotiators to handle the more specialized recovery tasks.Partnered with talent acquisition to interview, hire and onboard the newest recovery team member.Assumed the role of interim leader to conduct bi-weekly round table meetings, collect production data for the business, and take on all other duties expected of the acting manager as those needs arise. Show less

Managed Repair Representative

Columbus, Ohio

● Managing automobile physical damage repair projects helping clients to get back on the road.● Conducting supply chain purchasing decisions based on supplier part prices, availability, and deliverytime frames.● Discovering and documenting damages resulting from collision and comprehensive losses. Issuingtimely payments to expedite repairs.● Negotiating with shops to reach an agreed price to indemnify customers at the lowest cost.● Exploring trends in the auto insurance… Show more ● Managing automobile physical damage repair projects helping clients to get back on the road.● Conducting supply chain purchasing decisions based on supplier part prices, availability, and deliverytime frames.● Discovering and documenting damages resulting from collision and comprehensive losses. Issuingtimely payments to expedite repairs.● Negotiating with shops to reach an agreed price to indemnify customers at the lowest cost.● Exploring trends in the auto insurance industry to keep up with the rapidly changing environment ofauto manufacturer requirements, repair techniques, and technologies. Show less

Mar 2019 - Feb 2020

Automobile Subrogation Specialist

Columbus, Ohio Area

● Drafted and submitted demands to liable third-party carriers influencing others to pay our first-partycompany losses.● Prepared and filed contentions for inter-company arbitration hearings with a highly favorable award rate.● Negotiated maximum recoveries based on case evidence, state-specific tort law, and third-party auditreports.● Independently prioritized workload to manage 300-500 active claim files for expedited recovery.… Show more ● Drafted and submitted demands to liable third-party carriers influencing others to pay our first-partycompany losses.● Prepared and filed contentions for inter-company arbitration hearings with a highly favorable award rate.● Negotiated maximum recoveries based on case evidence, state-specific tort law, and third-party auditreports.● Independently prioritized workload to manage 300-500 active claim files for expedited recovery. ● Netted recoveries of $8.2 million total in the previous fiscal year (2017) distinguishing myself as the top recovery specialist for my team and 8th overall company-wide. My average monthly recovery earnings were 148% ahead of plan. Show less

2015 - Mar 2019

Property Subrogation Specialist

Columbus, Ohio Area

● Investigated claims for recovery potential in determining singular or multiple at-fault parties, evaluatedthe level of negligence contributed by each, submitted demands to the appropriate carriers, and closelymonitored the progress of claims to ensure payments are delivered expediently.● Negotiated settlements with liability insurance carriers to minimize first-party losses.● Netted recoveries earning the spot of top core subrogation specialist in Ohio.

2014 - 2015 ~1 yr

Property Claims Specialist

Columbus, Ohio Area

Responsible for delivering world class claim handling practices across a broad range of loss scenarios. Oversee managed repair projects with our preferred contractor network, maintaining reasonable timelines for the acquisition of materials and execution of labor.Evaluate losses to determine if potential coverage exclusions or limitations exist according to specific policy coverage forms.

Oct 2012 - 2014

Brewmaster

Barley'S Brewing Company

Columbus, Ohio

Responsible for the production of 1500 barrels of the highest quality craft beer in the Columbus vicinity valuing upwards of $13.5 million a year in gross revenue. Act as a company spokesperson at large tasting events to spread the philosophy of quality craftsmanship hereby contributing to an gross product sales increase of more than 60% over the 2013 sales total.

2010 - 2015 ~5 yrs

Insurance Sales Representative

Columbus, Ohio

● Built a successful $450K premium per year agency through exemplary sales performance andprocedural knowledge.● Collaborated with Marketing to recognize which design elements were most conducive to the customerexperience.● Created and implemented a successful Nationwide Insurance sales outlet dealing in multiple lines ofinsurance ranging from property and casualty to life products and annuities.

2005 - 2007 ~2 yrs

Associate Sales Agent & General Manager

Demont Insurance Agency

Tallahassee, Florida

● Engaged a salesforce of four personal lines producers, three commercial producers, and twolife/financial producers for consultative selling and goal achievement through teamwork.● Implemented a new information system client management tool and established connections with threestart-up insurance carriers to enhance the customer experience through ease of use and increased productoptions for hundreds of clients.● Diversified sales channels through the hiring of bilingual… Show more ● Engaged a salesforce of four personal lines producers, three commercial producers, and twolife/financial producers for consultative selling and goal achievement through teamwork.● Implemented a new information system client management tool and established connections with threestart-up insurance carriers to enhance the customer experience through ease of use and increased productoptions for hundreds of clients.● Diversified sales channels through the hiring of bilingual staff members and configuring our call matrixto route calls according to customer language needs.● Served as Subject Matter Expert holding weekly workshops to share product, underwriting, and salesknowledge with the agency workforce; organized a weekly round table sales meeting to discussagency-level opportunities and to recognize associate successes. Show less

2004 - 2005 ~1 yr

Policy Analyst/Underwriter

Gainesville, Florida

● Analysed data drawn from sales channel portfolio growth percentages and loss ratios to effectively minimize adverse selection of property and casualty risk.● Coordinated with the Nationwide Office of Product in the implementation of loss trend reduction strategies.● Developed and facilitated the Property Underwriting portion of ongoing Agency New Hire Training Classes. As co-coordinator of the program, planned overall framework to establish course structure and timeline.● Applied… Show more ● Analysed data drawn from sales channel portfolio growth percentages and loss ratios to effectively minimize adverse selection of property and casualty risk.● Coordinated with the Nationwide Office of Product in the implementation of loss trend reduction strategies.● Developed and facilitated the Property Underwriting portion of ongoing Agency New Hire Training Classes. As co-coordinator of the program, planned overall framework to establish course structure and timeline.● Applied technical expertise and astute decision-making skills in the evaluation of inspection material to assess insurability in case underwriting files. Show less

2002 - 2004 ~2 yrs
Team & coworkers

Colleagues at Hagerty

Other employees you can reach at hagerty-insurance.com. View company contacts for 11 employees →

1 education record

Stephen Lothrop education

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about Stephen Lothrop

Quick answers generated from the profile data available on this page.

What company does Stephen Lothrop work for?

Stephen Lothrop works for Hagerty.

What is Stephen Lothrop's role at Hagerty?

Stephen Lothrop is listed as Arbitration Specialist at Hagerty.

What is Stephen Lothrop's email address?

AeroLeads has found 1 work email signal at @hagerty.com for Stephen Lothrop at Hagerty.

What is Stephen Lothrop's phone number?

AeroLeads has found 5 phone signal(s) with area code 614, 352, 850 for Stephen Lothrop at Hagerty.

Where is Stephen Lothrop based?

Stephen Lothrop is based in Columbus, Ohio, United States while working with Hagerty.

What companies has Stephen Lothrop worked for?

Stephen Lothrop has worked for Hagerty, Progressive Insurance, Nationwide, Barley'S Brewing Company, and Nationwide Insurance.

Who are Stephen Lothrop's colleagues at Hagerty?

Stephen Lothrop's colleagues at Hagerty include Anita Tiwari, Luisa Dorough, Amy Boscarino, Allison Leman, and Ankur Mehta.

How can I contact Stephen Lothrop?

You can use AeroLeads to view verified contact signals for Stephen Lothrop at Hagerty, including work email, phone, and LinkedIn data when available.

What schools did Stephen Lothrop attend?

Stephen Lothrop holds Bachelor Of Arts (B.A.), Philosophy from University Of Florida.

What skills is Stephen Lothrop known for?

Stephen Lothrop is listed with skills including Food, Craft Beer, and Beer.

Find 750M verified contacts

Search by job title, company, industry, location, and seniority. Export verified B2B contact data when you need it.

People with similar names

Check these profiles if this is not the Stephen Lothrop you were looking for.

View similar profiles